Scrunchy Makeup & Nails: How to Upgrade Without Replacing Your Entire Bag | Non-Toxic Makeup | Scrunchy Living

Scrunchy Makeup & Nails: How to Upgrade Without Replacing Your Entire Bag

Key Takeaways

  • You don't need to throw out everything at once — swapping just your foundation and nail polish to cleaner formulas removes two of the highest-exposure sources of hormone-disrupting chemicals in a typical makeup routine.
  • "16-free" nail polish means the formula was made without 16 of the most concerning ingredients, including formaldehyde, toluene, and dibutyl phthalate — chemicals associated with hormone disruption and developmental concerns.
  • Cleaner makeup brands increasingly offer skin-care-forward formulas, so you can treat your skin while you wear coverage — a practical win when you're short on time and energy.

TL;DR:
- You don't have to replace your whole bag. Swap products as they run out, starting with the highest-impact ones.
- Prioritize the products with the most skin contact or near mucous membranes: makeup remover, foundation, mascara, and lip products.
- For nails, choose a 10-free or 16-free polish and an acetone-free remover; bring your own polish to the salon.

Feeling Overwhelmed by Your Makeup Bag? You're Not Alone.

If you've started down the clean-living rabbit hole and landed, panic-stricken, in front of your makeup drawer — this is for you. Swapping every product at once is expensive, exhausting, and honestly unnecessary. The goal here isn't a perfect, Instagram-worthy vanity. It's making smarter choices as products run out, starting with the ones that matter most.

There's real science behind why this is worth your attention, especially during pregnancy and the postpartum period. The skin absorbs compounds from products applied topically, and several ingredients commonly found in conventional cosmetics — including phthalates, parabens, and formaldehyde-releasing preservatives — are classified as endocrine disruptors (meaning they can interfere with your hormones) according to the NIH National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences. During pregnancy especially, even low-level hormonal interference is worth minimizing.

The good news: a few strategic swaps go a long way.

What Ingredients in Conventional Makeup Are Actually Concerning?

You don't need to memorize a chemistry textbook. Here are the four to keep on your radar:

Phthalates — often hidden under the word "fragrance" on ingredient labels — are endocrine disruptors linked to reproductive and developmental concerns. The Endocrine Society's scientific statement links phthalate exposure to effects on fetal reproductive development.

Formaldehyde and formaldehyde-releasing preservatives (like DMDM hydantoin and quaternium-15) are found in some foundations and nail polishes. The National Cancer Institute classifies formaldehyde as a human carcinogen and a known cause of skin and respiratory irritation.

PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances — sometimes called "forever chemicals" because they don't break down in the body or environment) have been detected in some long-wear foundations and waterproof cosmetics. The CDC's ATSDR describes PFAS as widespread chemicals of concern with potential effects on the immune system and hormones.

Talc — sometimes contaminated with asbestos — has historically appeared in loose powders and mineral makeup. Choosing talc-free formulas, especially during pregnancy, is a reasonable precaution.

If you only do one thing from this section, do this: Flip your current foundation and nail polish over and search the ingredient list for "fragrance," DMDM hydantoin, or dibutyl phthalate. That tells you where you stand right now.

How Do You Actually Upgrade Your Makeup Without Starting Over?

Start with the products you use most

The swap strategy that makes the most sense financially and practically: replace products as they run out, starting with the items you apply most frequently or over the largest surface area of skin.

Foundation is a great first swap because it covers the most skin. If you don't need it daily, reserve it for special occasions and let your skin breathe on regular days. A consistent skincare routine — gentle cleansing, a vitamin C serum, SPF — reduces how much coverage you feel like you need in the first place.

When you are ready to replace your foundation, look for formulas with added skincare ingredients so your skin gets something back while you're wearing coverage. CRUNCHI makes a high-performance, toxin-free foundation alongside their I Am Bright Vitamin C serum — both formulated without a long list of concerning chemicals. Maia's Minerals is another solid option: 100% natural, vegan, talc-free, and formulated without nanoparticles, making it a strong choice for pregnancy and sensitive skin.

SCRUNCHY MOM TIP: A good skincare routine — consistent moisturizing, a vitamin C serum, and SPF — means less foundation is needed to achieve a healthy, even look. Less product on your skin is always a win.

Concealer and mascara are also high-priority swaps since they're applied close to eyes and mucous membranes, where absorption can be higher.

For makeup removal, look for oil-based options that are gentle on the eye area. Be Natural Organics makes a Purifying Oil Treatment that doubles as an effective eye makeup remover, using a blend of organic oils — pad it on and let it sit before using gentle friction to remove. No harsh rubbing, no mystery chemicals near your eyes.

Honest Beauty is another well-rounded option for makeup and skincare — their entire line is formulated without parabens, phthalates, and other commonly flagged ingredients, and they offer a range of everyday essentials from tinted moisturizer to mascara.

Start here this week: Swap your makeup remover first. It's inexpensive, you use it every day, and it directly affects skin around your eyes and lips.

What Is 16-Free Nail Polish — and Does It Actually Matter?

16-free means the polish was formulated without 16 of the most concerning ingredients typically found in conventional nail polish. The "dirty dozen" in conventional polish includes formaldehyde (a known sensitizer and carcinogen), toluene (a solvent that may affect the nervous system), dibutyl phthalate or DBP (an endocrine disruptor), and camphor — among others. The EWG has documented the hazard concerns associated with many nail care ingredients, including their potential hormone-disrupting and respiratory effects.

Does it matter? Yes — especially if you're getting your nails done regularly or you're pregnant. Nail salons in particular can have high concentrations of VOCs (volatile organic compounds — airborne chemicals released from products like polish and remover that you can breathe in). Choosing cleaner polish reduces your personal exposure even if you can't control everything in the salon environment.

Good brands to look for:
- Ella+Mila — widely available, budget-friendly, 17-free formula
- Olive and June — 8-free, accessible at most drugstores, good for at-home manicures
- Mineral Fusion — 10-free, EWG Verified, 100% vegan and cruelty-free; also makes a nail polish remover that's acetone-free
- Karma Organic Rose Remover — a gentler, rose-based remover option; pad on and let sit before wiping

SCRUNCHY MOM TIP: Cleaner polish brands may not last as long as conventional formulas — using a base coat and top coat from the same brand can meaningfully extend wear time. If you love salon manicures, look for holistic or "non-toxic" nail studios that use 16-free polishes, or bring your own polish — call ahead and ask. It's one of the easiest ways to control what goes on your nails without giving up the experience.

If you only do one thing from this section, do this: Next time your nail polish runs out, replace it with an Ella+Mila or Mineral Fusion option. It's a one-time, low-cost swap that eliminates formaldehyde and phthalates from something you may wear continuously.

A Note for Pregnant and Postpartum Mamas

The first trimester is the highest-priority window to simplify your routine — organ development is happening rapidly, and the placenta is not a perfect barrier to all chemical exposures. ACOG advises reducing prenatal exposure to toxic environmental agents, including chemicals in personal care products, during pregnancy.

Postpartum skin is often more reactive and sensitive due to hormonal shifts, which makes this a practical moment (not just a philosophical one) to simplify. Fewer products, cleaner ingredients, and a skin-nourishing routine tend to work better than layering heavy conventional coverage on compromised skin.

If you're on a tight budget, start with nail polish and makeup remover and don't stress yet about replacing every product. Those two swaps are low-cost, high-impact, and require zero overhaul of the rest of your routine.

Good Brands to Buy

  • Mineral Fusion — EWG Verified nail polish and remover; 10-free, vegan, widely available (budget-friendly option)
  • Ella+Mila — 17-free nail polish, extensive shade range, drugstore-accessible
  • Olive and June — 8-free polish, great for at-home manicure kits
  • Karma Organic Rose Remover — gentle, rose-based nail polish remover; less harsh than acetone formulas
  • Be Natural Organics Purifying Oil Treatment — spa-grade organic eye makeup remover
  • Honest Beauty — everyday makeup essentials without parabens, phthalates, or synthetic fragrance
  • CRUNCHI — toxin-free foundation and Vitamin C serum; performance-focused clean beauty
  • Maia's Minerals — talc-free, nanoparticle-free mineral makeup; strong pregnancy-safe option

FAQ

Q: Do I have to replace my entire makeup bag when I get pregnant?

No — and the pressure to do so all at once is one of the biggest barriers to actually making any changes. Prioritize the products with the highest daily use and largest skin-surface coverage: foundation, concealer, and anything applied near your eyes or lips. Replace them as they run out with cleaner alternatives. That's a genuinely meaningful upgrade without the financial stress of a full overhaul.

Q: Is nail polish safe during pregnancy?

Conventional nail polish contains ingredients — including formaldehyde, toluene, and dibutyl phthalate — that are concerning during pregnancy, particularly with repeated exposure. Switching to a 16-free or 10-free formula significantly reduces exposure to those specific chemicals. If you're getting salon manicures, ensure the space is well-ventilated, and consider bringing your own cleaner polish. Occasional use with a cleaner formula is considered a much lower-risk option than regular use of conventional polish.

Q: What does "EWG Verified" actually mean on a beauty product?

EWG Verified is a certification from the Environmental Working Group — an independent nonprofit research organization — indicating that a product meets their strictest standards for ingredient safety, full transparency on the label, and responsible manufacturing practices. It means the brand has disclosed all ingredients (including fragrance components), and none of those ingredients appear on EWG's "unacceptable" list. It's one of the more rigorous third-party certifications available for personal care products, though it's not the only meaningful marker of a cleaner formula. Learn more at EWG.org.

Shop These Recommendations

Product Why It's Worth It Amazon
Honest Company / Honest Beauty A brand dedicated to 'clean, conscious' products for baby and beauty. Their line is made… Buy on Amazon
Be Natural Organics A spa-grade organic skincare line. Their 'Purifying Oil Treatment' doubles as an… Buy on Amazon
CRUNCHI A brand committed to high-performance, toxin-free cosmetics and skincare. Crunchi's…
Maia's Mineral A natural and mineral-based makeup brand. Maia's Minerals products are 100% natural…
Mineral Fusion A brand of natural, EWG Verified cosmetics. Mineral Fusion's nail polish and removers are… Buy on Amazon

About the Author

Jenn Smith, RN BSN, is a registered nurse, mom, and co-founder of Scrunchy Living. She writes evidence-based guides to non-toxic living, pregnancy-safe products, and clean home practices for modern families.

You Might Also Like

Medical Disclaimer: The information in this article is intended for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. It is not a substitute for professional medical guidance, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your OB-GYN, midwife, or a qualified healthcare provider with questions about your health during pregnancy or postpartum. Individual health circumstances vary, and what is appropriate for one person may not be appropriate for another.

Back to blog