Natural Teething Relief for Babies: What Actually Works - Scrunchy Living

Natural Teething Relief for Babies: What Actually Works

Teething is uncomfortable for babies and exhausting for parents, but most of the remedies marketed for it are either ineffective or actively unsafe.

TL;DR:
- Skip benzocaine gels, amber necklaces, and most over-the-counter teething tablets — safer, effective options exist.
- Chilled (not frozen) teethers, gum massage, and breastfeeding on demand are the most reliably soothing approaches.
- A few clean-ingredient herbal and homeopathic products can help when you need extra support.

Key Takeaways

  • The FDA has warned against benzocaine-based teething gels and certain homeopathic teething tablets due to documented safety risks in infants.
  • Babies can begin teething as early as 3 to 4 months, so having a plan before the fussing starts is worth the preparation.
  • Simple, low-cost interventions like gum massage with coconut oil and chilled washcloths are among the most effective first-line options.

Why Does Teething Hurt So Much (and Why Are So Many Remedies Useless)?

If your baby is drooling through three bibs a day, gnawing on your shoulder, and waking every two hours at night, you are not imagining things. Teething genuinely hurts. As teeth push through the gum tissue, localized inflammation causes soreness, tenderness, and that relentless need to bite down on anything within reach.

The problem is that the teething remedy aisle is full of products that either don't work or carry real risks. Knowing which category each remedy falls into will save you money, stress, and a potential trip to urgent care.

What Teething Symptoms Actually Look Like

Drooling, gum swelling, fussiness, and a strong urge to chew are all typical teething signs. A mild temperature elevation is sometimes reported, but the American Academy of Pediatrics does not consider a true fever (above 100.4°F) to be a teething symptom. If your baby has a fever, rule out illness first.

Babies can begin teething as early as 3 to 4 months. Many parents notice increased mouthing behavior even before a tooth is visible. This oral exploration, sometimes called oral mapping, is developmentally normal and actually supports sensory development as long as the objects babies mouth are clean and not choking hazards.

What this means for your family: Start assembling a teething toolkit around month 3 so you are not scrambling at 2 a.m. when the first tooth arrives.

What Actually Helps: Safe, Effective Teething Relief

Does gum massage really work?

Yes. Applying gentle, firm pressure to the gum directly above an emerging tooth counteracts the pressure building from below, which is why babies instinctively bite down on everything. Use a clean finger to massage the gums for one to two minutes.

For extra soothing effect, apply a small amount of organic coconut oil before massaging. Coconut oil has mild anti-inflammatory properties and is safe if swallowed. If your baby is older and you want a stronger option, a single drop of diluted clove oil (clove essential oil diluted heavily in a carrier like coconut oil) can be added. Clove contains eugenol, a natural analgesic, but use it sparingly and only with older babies.

SCRUNCHY MOM TIP: Less is more with clove oil. One small drop in a tablespoon of coconut oil is sufficient. Undiluted essential oils are not safe for infants.

Can breastfeeding help with teething pain?

Breastfeeding is one of the most underrated teething tools available. Nursing provides comfort on a neurological level and breast milk contains pain-modulating peptides and immune factors that can ease inflammation. Breastfeeding on demand during teething flares is completely appropriate — a Cochrane review found breastfeeding measurably reduces infants' pain during painful procedures, the same soothing, pain-modulating effect many parents rely on during teething.

Breast milk popsicles are another option. Pump a small amount of milk, freeze it in a mesh feeder or silicone mold, and let your baby gnaw on it under close supervision. The cold numbs the gums and the milk provides familiar comfort.

What this means for your family: If your baby is nursing more frequently during teething, that is biologically appropriate. Follow their lead.

Are cold teethers actually effective?

Cold temperature reduces localized inflammation and temporarily numbs gum tissue, which is why chilled teethers consistently show up in evidence-based recommendations. The Mayo Clinic recommends chilled (not frozen) teething rings as a safe, effective option.

Frozen-solid teethers can be too hard and may bruise already-tender gum tissue. Refrigerator-cold is the target. A damp washcloth chilled in the refrigerator and tied in a knot works just as well as a specialty product and costs nothing.

For rubber teethers specifically, natural rubber is a cleaner material than PVC or silicone blended with fillers. Look for 100% natural rubber with no added dyes or BPA. Good brands include Hevea, Moonjax, Vulli, and CaaOcho. These teethers double as sensory toys that support fine motor development.

What about herbal and homeopathic teething products?

This is where it gets nuanced. Some herbal and homeopathic products are well-formulated and have a reasonable safety record. Others have been flagged by the FDA.

The FDA has specifically warned against certain homeopathic teething tablets that were found to contain inconsistent levels of belladonna, a plant with anticholinergic properties that can be dangerous in infants. This FDA action, confirmed by the American Academy of Pediatrics, is worth knowing before purchasing any teething tablet.

That said, several cleaner options exist:

  • Boiron Camilia — single-dose liquid drops in sterile vials. Plant-based, benzocaine-free, and formulated without belladonna. One of the most well-regarded homeopathic teething options currently on the market.
  • Hylands Baby Oral Pain Relief — gentle homeopathic formula free from artificial flavors and dyes. Hyland's has reformulated since the earlier FDA concerns; check that you are purchasing a current version.
  • Earthley Teeth Tamer — an herbal extract made with organic, responsibly sourced ingredients and no synthetic fillers. A solid option from a family-owned brand with transparent sourcing.
  • Rowe Casa Organics Baby Teething Oil — a plant-based teething oil made in small batches. Clean ingredient list with no unnecessary additives.

What this means for your family: Choose homeopathic teething products that are transparent about ingredient amounts and free from benzocaine and belladonna.

What to Skip: Teething Remedies That Aren't Worth the Risk

Why are benzocaine gels a problem?

Benzocaine-containing products like Baby Orajel were once the go-to recommendation. The FDA has since issued strong warnings against them. Benzocaine can cause methemoglobinemia, a condition in which the blood cannot carry oxygen effectively, which the FDA has warned is a serious risk in infants and young children. There is no teething benefit that justifies this risk when safer alternatives exist.

Are amber teething necklaces safe?

No. Baltic amber necklaces are marketed on the idea that succinic acid releases from the amber and absorbs through the skin to reduce inflammation. There is no clinical evidence supporting this mechanism in infants. More importantly, any necklace worn by a baby while sleeping or unsupervised is a strangulation and choking hazard. The American Academy of Pediatrics does not recommend them.

Teething Relief at a Glance

Method Best For Budget-Friendly? Safety Notes
Gum massage with coconut oil All teething stages Yes Always clean hands first
Chilled rubber teether Active chewing phase Mid-range Never freeze solid
Chilled damp washcloth First-time parents, budget households Free Refrigerate, do not freeze
Breastfeeding on demand Breastfed babies any stage Yes Biologically appropriate
Breast milk popsicle 4+ months with mesh feeder Yes Supervise always
Boiron Camilia drops Extra support needed Mid-range Benzocaine-free, plant-based
Earthley Teeth Tamer Herbal-preferred families Mid-range Organic ingredients
Rowe Casa Teething Oil Topical herbal option Mid-range Small-batch, clean label

FAQ

Q: My baby is 3 months old and chewing on everything. Is that teething?

It can be, but increased mouthing at 3 months is also a normal developmental milestone called oral mapping. Babies use their mouths to explore texture, temperature, and shape. Whether a tooth is imminent or not, this is a good time to introduce a clean natural rubber teether. If gum swelling and irritability accompany the chewing, teething is the more likely cause.

Q: Is it safe to rub whiskey or alcohol on baby's gums?

No. Even small amounts of alcohol are unsafe for infants and can cause blood sugar drops and other physiological effects. This is a remedy from an earlier era when the risks were less understood. Stick to coconut oil, clean herbal preparations, or the physical methods described above.

Q: How long does teething last?

Individual teeth typically cause discomfort for a few days before and after eruption. The entire teething process spans from roughly 3 to 4 months through approximately age 3, when most toddlers have their full set of primary teeth. The worst discomfort is usually associated with molars, which tend to arrive between 12 and 18 months. Having a consistent relief strategy in place will make the long haul more manageable.

About the Author

Jenn Smith, RN BSN, is a registered nurse, mom, and co-founder of Scrunchy Living. She writes evidence-based guides to non-toxic living, pregnancy-safe products, and clean home practices for modern families.

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult your pediatrician or qualified healthcare provider before introducing new remedies, supplements, or products to your infant, especially if your baby has known allergies, underlying health conditions, or is under 3 months of age.

Shop These Recommendations

Product Why It's Worth It Amazon
Boiron A world leader in homeopathic medicines. Their "Camila" teething drops are plant-based…
Hylands Hyland's makes gentle homeopathic medicines crafted from natural active ingredients to…
Earthley A family-owned herbal wellness brand; their Teeth Tamer extract uses organic, responsibly sourced ingredients with no synthetic fillers.
Boiron Camilia Single-dose liquid teething drops — plant-based, benzocaine-free, and formulated without belladonna.
Rowe Casa Organics Rowe Casa Organics is a family-owned natural wellness company making low-tox, plant-based…

From Scrunchy Living: The Non-Toxic Home Starter Kit ($74.99) replaces your household cleaners with one EWG Verified concentrate — quats-free, fragrance-free, and safe for pregnancy and babies. Includes a full year of ScrunchyAI, our ingredient-scanning tool for non-toxic families. Start your free 14-day trial →

You Might Also Like

Back to blog